Georgia Institute of Technology Georgia Institute of Technology

Research Horizons

Georgia Tech's Research Horizons Magazine

Negative Science

A stack of published journals

The number of times academic articles are cited by subsequent publications is among the measures used to assess scholarly standing. But not all citations are positive ones, and a paper published in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences found that as many as one in 50 citations in a top immunology journal were critical in nature.

Negative citations may point out limitations, inconsistencies, or flaws in previous work. The study found that these negative citations tended to originate from scholars who were close to the authors of the original articles in academic discipline — but at least 150 miles away geographically.

The research, by authors at Georgia Tech, the University of Toronto, and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, may be the first to systematically quantify and examine negative citations. “Given that we rely so heavily on these citation metrics as measures of quality, it’s important to note that the intent of these citations isn’t homogeneous,” said Alexander Oettl, an assistant professor in Georgia Tech’s Scheller College of Business. 

— John Toon

Alexander Oettl

Alexander Oettl is an assistant professor in Georgia Tech’s Scheller College of Business.

Subscribe to Research Horizons
Get the latest Georgia Tech research news through our free print magazine, monthly electronic newsletter, and Twitter feed.


Georgia Tech is home to more than 2,500 faculty members who conduct scientific and engineering research in hundreds of different research areas.

Related Stories

Read More
Read More
Read More

Media Contacts

John Toon

John Toon

Director of Research News
Phone: 404.894.6986

Subscribe & Connect

Follow Us on Twitter:


RSS Feeds

Subscribe to our RSS Feeds with your favorite reader.

Email Newsletter

Sign up to receive our monthly email newsletter.

Research Horizons Magazine

Sign up for a free subscription to Research Horizons magazine.